Ref Base – Video Evaluations

Blue Adidas short-sleeve athletic shirt
Go back
Evaluator Email
canicho12@aol.com
Date / Time of Match
09/28/2024 10:30 AM
Field Location of Match
SC 14 N
Evaluator Name
Cindy Spring
Referee Name
Jeremiah Garcia
Positioning/Movement
3 = Needs Improvement
Decision Making/Rules Application
3 = Needs Improvement
Interaction with Team
3 = Needs Improvement
Signaling:
2 = Satisfactory
Positioning/Movement Comments
Behind play and his back is to AR 1 missing calls. Example would be at 9:54 he started to make a call looked at the AR1 and correct the call to what the AR1 had indicated. 5:13 well behind play at the time of the goal.
Decision Making/Rules Application: Comments
Drop ball needs to be reviewed for the new way of doing it. Fouls were recognized but through the game escalated in severity. In my opinion at 19:48 a yellow card could have been issued. At 54:27 a yellow card could have been issued as there was no attempt to play the ball. At 1:00:28 another yellow could have been issued. At 1:04:36 a red card could have been issued as the player openly shoved the player off the ball.
Signaling Coments
should look at the AR before signaling when he is unsure of the call.
Interaction with Team Comments
Need to have a better view of AR 1.
Comments for the Assignor (will not get sent to mentee)
Wrist band on a blue players wrist. Leads me to think law 4 was not reviewed at check in. Failed to have all substitute's off the field before restarting the game. 6:27 indecisive call example. Does not appear to look at AR1 before he begins to signal. 9:54 another example. Has his back to AR1 in plays that had his position been better he could have used AR1's input. 19:48 possible yellow card. Game is escalating, 54:05 AR2 called offside near the half line. Center allowed the ball to go to the keeper. In my opinion the offside should have been called as it put the team in a better position. (the goalie did a good punt though) 54:27 yellow card no attempt to play the ball. 1:00:28 should have been a yellow. 1:04:36 Red card There were many fouls that were called but the above times are were based on the tape I would have carded. Had he carded at the 19th minute the game may not have escalated the way it did. I don't think he communicates wit the players. Had he talked to the players to indicate what he was calling the kids may have adjusted their game instead of pushing it to see what they could get away with. Just a suggestion maybe a game or two at U9 and U10 will give him a better understanding of how to use AR's. What I mean is doing a game alone makes you think about your position and process more information as it is only you.. So when you go back to having AR's you understand their importance and utilize them better. From what I understand Brandon has plenty of games without ref's.
Referee Email
garciajeremiah0934@gmail.com
Is this form complete?
Yes
Positioning along touchline during active play and staying at the offside line
Position at corner for signaling GK or CK
Accuracy when signaling offside:
Comment on offside signaling
Correct mechanics when signaling for offside
Accuracy when signaling throw-ins
Correct mechanics when signaling throw-ins
Comment on throw-in signaling
Proper hand for carrying the flag when not signaling:
Accuracy and mechanics when signaling fouls in AR’s area:
Accuracy and mechanics when signaling GK and CK
Positioning for a Penalty Kick
4-PK Did Not Occur
Made eye contact with Referee/AR when needed:
3 = Needs Improvement
Did the referee have the proper jersey and badge and was the jersey tucked in an worn approriatley
No
Did the referee wear black shorts
Yes
Did the referee wear black socks that were pulled up just below the knee
Yes
Uniform/Appearance comments
Shirt was not tucked into his shorts. A conversation should have been had at the start so that AR 1 had his shirt tucked in as well.
Assignor Access Only
Assignor's Password
Entered Into Ref Base
Comments for the Referee
Hi, you should present yourself as a professional when refereeing a game. Your shirt should be tucked into you shorts. When checking in please ensure that players do not have items that should be removed. Work on recognizing the AR's especially AR1 as you make calls. If you are not sure, their information makes a better impression as you make the call together as a team.
Fouls: you recognize fouls, however there were 5 incidents where a yellow or a red could have been issued. Had you issued the yellow when it was warranted in the firsst half the game may not have escalated to where it did by the end of the game. The game got away from you as the players tested what they could get away with. I could not tell if you were communicating with the players but it helps when you tell them what is being called. It doesn't have to be a discussion. An example is running with them "play the ball not the player" they know what you mean and they are on notice you are watching.
Position of Referee being evaluated
CR
Are you evaluating yourself or someone else?
Someone Else
Key moments (to also be included in referee education)
Time
1:04:36
Description of the moments
See above for the 5 times. 1:04:36 should have been a red card for shoving the player in my opinion. Had it been me there would have been a red for VC.
Time
1:04:36
Description of the moments
See above for the 5 times.

1:04:36 should have been a red card for shoving the player in my opinion. Had it been me there would have been a red for VC.
Match Number
4047
Assign an Evaluator (assignor only)
Yes
Post Meeting Notes (please list the date and time you meet and any commentsO
Jeremiah has not made time to meet even though we have reached out on several occasions
Have you met with the Referee?
No
Message to Referee to invite them to meeting
I am available most evenings after 5:00 or on Sunday mornings. my phone number is 505-228-4187 and my email is canicho12@aol.com.

Cindy Spring
Is this a youth Referee?
Yes
Parent Email
miguel0220garcia@gmail.com
Send Referee Meeting Invitation
Yes
Entry Update Date
November 3, 2024